The Civic Broadside · Where did all the money go?

State Delegation Settles In

The September 1 primary brought out more voters than in recent years -- and left Malden's own candidates on the losing end of two district-wide races they won at home

WBUR reported results of the Sept. 1, 2026 Massachusetts state House and Senate primaries. We've drawn on their AP race-call data, plus the Malden City Clerk's posted results, throughout this piece.1

National news focused on U.S. Sen. Ed Markey's convincing 64.9% win over U.S. Rep. Seth Moulton in the Democratic primary. Markey, a Malden native, did even better at home: 81.7% of the vote in his home city. But two other races on the same ballot will actually reshape Malden's state delegation -- and both of them turned out differently in Malden than they did across the rest of the district.

WBUR/AP results page for the 2026 Massachusetts U.S. Senate Democratic primary, showing Markey's statewide win and a Malden-specific tally of 5,577 votes (81.7%) for Markey to 1,253 (18.4%) for Moulton.
Markey's Malden numbers, via WBUR/AP.

Statewide, Markey took 572,595 votes (64.9%) to Moulton's 310,365 (35.2%). In Malden alone, Markey's home-field advantage was even more lopsided: 5,577 votes (81.7%) to 1,253 (18.4%).

The House Race: Melrose's Migliorelli Wins the District, Loses Malden

Leila Bhatti Migliorelli, of Melrose, is on her way to filling Kate Lipper-Garabedian's old seat as the 32nd Middlesex District's Democratic state representative -- covering parts of Malden, Melrose, and Wakefield. Migliorelli defeated John Higgins, who had Mayor Gary Christenson's endorsement, by roughly two-to-one. Morning estimates on Sept. 2 had her at 66.6% of the vote; by the afternoon, with 99% of votes counted, that had climbed to a final 71.5% (5,772 votes) to Higgins's 28.5% (2,303).

Malden itself didn't go along with that result. In the city's own precincts, Higgins actually won, 61.8% (395 votes) to Migliorelli's 38.2% (244) -- Malden was the one community in the district that backed the mayor's endorsed, hometown-adjacent candidate, even as Melrose and Wakefield carried Migliorelli to a decisive district-wide win.

The Higgins campaign also ran into what the Melrose Messenger called "an unusual move": in August, the Massachusetts Teachers Association withdrew its endorsement of Higgins after he posted a campaign video criticizing his opponent's role in Melrose's Proposition 2½ override, which raised property taxes citywide.2 The irony, as the Messenger also noted, is that Higgins's own endorser, Malden Mayor Christenson, put forward an override vote of his own in Malden.

The Senate Race: Lipper-Garabedian Wins the District, Loses Malden

Kate Lipper-Garabedian won the Fifth Middlesex Democratic Senate primary outright, taking 63.5% of the vote (15,727 votes) against two sitting Malden city councillors: Carey McDonald (23.3%, 5,763 votes) and Ryan J. O'Malley (13.2%, 3,273 votes). The seat represents six communities -- Malden, Melrose, Reading, Stoneham, Wakefield, and Winchester -- and opened up when Sen. Jason Lewis announced his retirement in February.

As in the House race, Malden's own votes told a different story than the district as a whole. Within Malden, McDonald actually finished first: 44.4% (2,874 votes) to Lipper-Garabedian's 34.4% (2,227) and O'Malley's 21.3% (1,380). McDonald carried their home city -- and still lost the seat by nearly 40 points district-wide.

That split points to a rougher night for Mayor Christenson who endorsed both losing candidates, Higgins and McDonald, and contributed to McDonald's campaign. This puts Christenson at odds with the Governor and every other member of Malden's state delegation, who lined up behind Lipper-Garabedian. Both of the mayor's picks carried Malden. Neither carried the district.

Ballotpedia's Fifth Middlesex Democratic primary page showing an earlier, partial-count snapshot: Lipper-Garabedian 73.5% (10,444), McDonald 16.1% (2,293), O'Malley 10.3% (1,469), total 14,206 votes, with a note that totals may change until certified.
A caution about counting sources: Ballotpedia's page (above) reflects an earlier, partial count -- about 14,200 votes total, versus the AP's later, 99%-counted call of nearly 24,800. The vote totals and shares in this piece use the AP/WBUR figures throughout, as the more complete count.3

Turnout: More Voters, About the Same Rate

Malden's Sept. 1 turnout was 20.5% -- 38,625 registered voters, 7,950 ballots cast. That's slightly below the 21.8% turnout of the November 2023 municipal election, but it produced more actual ballots, because the voter rolls have grown. Malden has added roughly 2,600 registered voters since 2023.

November 2025 was the quiet year by comparison: only 15% of Malden's then-37,854 registered voters turned out, for 5,805 ballots cast -- even though 2025 was a citywide municipal election, the kind of race that often drives turnout higher, not lower.

Malden turnout, three elections
ElectionRegistered votersBallots castTurnout
Sept. 1, 2026 -- State Primary (preliminary)38,6257,95020.5%
Nov. 4, 2025 -- Municipal Election37,8545,80515.0%
Nov. 7, 2023 -- Municipal Election36,0167,85621.8%
Side-by-side turnout summary tables for the 2026 state primary, 2025 municipal election, and 2023 municipal election, broken down by Malden ward and precinct.
Ward-by-ward turnout across all three elections. Ward 4 -- Councillor Ryan O'Malley's home ward -- has consistently had the fewest registered voters of Malden's eight wards.

Two Councillors, Two Very Different First Steps Up

Digging into the numbers raises its own questions about political trends in Malden. Carey McDonald won 4,384 citywide votes running for Councillor-at-Large in 2023. In 2025, running for the same seat with lower turnout, McDonald won significantly fewer votes -- 3,056. And now, in 2026's highest-turnout year of the three, McDonald's Malden vote count slipped again, to 2,874 -- even in a race they won at home. Three elections, the same name on the ballot, and a shrinking vote count every time.

For Ward 4 Councillor Ryan O'Malley, the story is closer to the opposite: this was his first citywide, multi-city campaign. Ward 4 has the smallest number of registered voters of Malden's eight wards, which makes O'Malley's jump to a six-community state Senate race a considerably bigger stage than his home turf.

Follow the Money

We reviewed campaign finance filings from the Massachusetts Office of Campaign and Political Finance for all three Senate candidates and built out some comparisons of our own.4 Carey McDonald brought in the most out-of-state money of the three: just 61.5% of their 2026 contributions came from Massachusetts addresses -- meaning nearly 40% of their money came from outside the state, compared with roughly 8% for Lipper-Garabedian and 7% for O'Malley.

Lipper-Garabedian led the way in total spending, with $164,648.47 reported spent year-to-date -- more than three times what McDonald spent ($46,303.70) and eighteen times O'Malley's total ($9,214.39). She also outspent what she'd raised in the race itself ($68,862.40), a gap her campaign's own committee history helps explain: OCPF filings show a $70,000 transfer into her account from a prior committee (from her time on the Melrose School Committee and City Council), money that predates this Senate race and isn't counted as a new 2026 donation in our analysis.

Measured by cost per vote, O'Malley ran the leanest campaign of the three: $2.82 spent per vote received, against $8.03 for McDonald and $10.47 for Lipper-Garabedian.

Table summarizing 2026 OCPF contribution data for McDonald, Lipper-Garabedian, and O'Malley: donation counts, totals, averages, in-state/out-of-state splits, Malden-connected donations, and Malden-resident donor shares.
The full contribution breakdown, from our OCPF analysis workbook. McDonald drew the most Malden-resident donor dollars in raw terms (39.8% of their total); O'Malley's donor base skewed even more Malden-heavy by share (62.0%), despite raising the least overall.
Six stacked bar charts comparing the three Senate candidates on total 2026 donations, average donation size, Massachusetts share of donations, Malden-connected donations, blank occupation/employer share, and dollars raised per vote.
Fundraising efficiency, several ways: dollars raised per vote received was $6.96 for McDonald, $4.96 for Lipper-Garabedian, and $2.13 for O'Malley -- a different ranking than the spending-per-vote numbers above, since it measures money in rather than money out.

The House Race, Town by Town

Disclaimers: contribution and expenditure filings may still be in transit or unrecorded at the time of this story -- treat the 2026 year-to-date totals above as a snapshot, not a finely tuned tally. Some figures in this piece were transcribed by hand or with AI assistance and, while we made a reasonable effort at accuracy, errors are possible. Official public records, linked below, should be treated as the final word.

Sources & Documents
  • State Primary, Sept. 1, 2026 -- Preliminary Results (Malden)
    View PDF →
  • Municipal Election, Nov. 4, 2025 -- Final Results (Malden)
    View PDF →
  • Municipal Election, Nov. 7, 2023 -- Final Results (Malden)
    View PDF →
  • OCPF Contribution Analysis -- Fifth Middlesex Senate Primary (2026)
    View PDF →
  • Malden Election Results (City of Malden)
    The city's official election-results portal.
    View source →
  • Ballotpedia: Kate Lipper-Garabedian
    Partial-count snapshot of the Fifth Middlesex primary; see caution above.
    View source →
  • WBUR: Massachusetts primary results, Beacon Hill races
    AP race-call data for state House and Senate primaries, used throughout this piece.
    View source →
  • The Melrose Messenger: MTA endorsement withdrawal
    Reporting on the Massachusetts Teachers Association's withdrawal of its endorsement of John Higgins.
    View source →
  • OCPF Filer Search
    Search portal for all campaign finance filings referenced in this piece.
    View source →
Notes
  1. WBUR / AP, "Massachusetts primary: Beacon Hill representative, Senate election," race-call data as updated Sept. 2, 2026, 9:54 a.m. (99% of votes counted). https://www.wbur.org/news/2026/09/01/massachusetts-primary-beacon-hill-representative-senate-election ←
  2. The Melrose Messenger, reporting on the Massachusetts Teachers Association's withdrawal of its endorsement of John Higgins, August 2026. https://themelrosemessenger.org/articles/2026/election/mta.html ←
  3. Ballotpedia, "Kate Lipper-Garabedian," Fifth Middlesex Democratic primary results page (partial-count snapshot). https://ballotpedia.org/Kate_Lipper-Garabedian ←
  4. Massachusetts Office of Campaign and Political Finance (OCPF), filer search. https://www.ocpf.us/Filers ←
A disclosure: This article was reported and written using public records: the Malden City Clerk's precinct-level results for the Sept. 1, 2026 state primary, the Nov. 4, 2025 and Nov. 7, 2023 municipal elections; AP/WBUR race-call data; Ballotpedia; the Melrose Messenger; and OCPF (Office of Campaign and Political Finance) contribution and expenditure filings for the three Fifth Middlesex Senate candidates. AI assistance was provided under the supervision of The Civic Broadside's editorial team. Facts, direct quotes, and vote/dollar figures have been checked against the original source documents listed under Sources & Documents below.
Corrections: This piece reflects our understanding of the matter as of publication and is based on public documents. We make reasonable efforts to ensure substantial accuracy. If you believe we've gotten a significant fact wrong, please email us so we can look into it.
Email: MaldenNewsNetwork@gmail.com